The Rig Vedic Ramayana - 2
anandhudli at HOTMAIL.COM
Sat Apr 8 11:08:15 CDT 2000
On Sat, 8 Apr 2000 03:14:41 EDT, Ashish Chandra <ramkisno at HOTMAIL.COM>
>In the English translation of Sayana's commentary of the RgVeda, 10th
>madala, 99th sukta, the 1st and the 2nd Rk are translated differently.
You bring up an excellent point. I was waiting for someone to bring it
up. sAyaNAchArya's is the standard interpretation based on the assumption
that the saMhitA portions (mantras) belong to the karma kANDa. But
nIlakaNTha gives a different interpretation based on the view that
the mantras really are something more than having to do with the karma
kANDa. This view is justified because the sUktas, especially of the
Rig Veda, are really prayers addressed to Gods. As such, these prayers
can be studied either in isolation or in the context of karma. There is,
for example, a view that the ViShNu-sahasra-nAma, nay the mahAbhArata
itself, is based on the Vedas. If epics such as the rAmAyaNa and the
'bhArata are based on the Vedas, there *has* to be some correspondence
between the epics and the Vedas. This is what nIlakaNTha has done in
the case of the rAmAyaNa. He identifies the exact mantras in the Rig Veda
that correspond to the contents of the rAmAyaNa. I have heard that he has
also written another text called the mantra-bhAgavata wherein he has
identified the mantras in the Rig Veda that correspond to the contents
of the bhAgavata. This is based on the view that the bhAgavata in its
entirety is, like the rAmAyaNa, based on the gAyatrI mantra. And the
gAyatrI mantra is the essence of the Vedas.
Both sAyaNAchArya's and nIlakaNTha's interpretations are valid but they
are valid in different contexts, sAyaNa's in the context of karmas, and
nIlakaNTha's in the context of bhakti or upAsana.
>Below, I am giving the translation from the Sarasvati-Sindhu civilization
>>From: Anand Hudli <anandhudli at HOTMAIL.COM>
>>Rig Veda 10.99.1:
>> kaM nashchitramishhaNyasi chikitvAnpR^ithugmAnaM vAshraM vAvR^idhadhyai
>> kattasya dAtu shavaso vyushhTau taxadvajraM vR^itraturamapinvat.h ||
>> O Guru! Who is the praiseworthy, charming person with virtues such as
>> valor and strength, whom you inspire us to glorify? And by extolling
>> Him what result (fruit) can His power can give me? (In reply, it is
>> stated,) by sharpening the viveka (discrimination between the eternal
>> and noneternal), He (rAma) will destroy the vR^itra demon of ignorance!
>10.099.01 What marvellous (wealth), comprehensive and laudable, do you,
>Indra, knowing (what is needed), bestow upon us for our advantage? What
>(has been made to us) upon the development of his strength? He fabricated
>the Vr.tra-slaying thunderbolt, and let the waters flow.
>>Rig Veda 10.99.2:
>> sa hi dyutA vidyutA veti sAmapR^ithuM yonimasuratvA sasAda |
>> sa sanILebhiH prasahAno asya bhrAturna R^ite saptathasya mAyAH |
>> By His brilliance and prowess, rAma with His (vAnara) forces,
>> the prolonged onslaught of rAvaNa's illusion tactics (mAyA) in battle,
>> destroyed the same rAvaNa along with all his mAyA. rAvaNa, the asura,
>> (earlier) stolen the daughter of the Earth, sItA, the wife of rAma who
>> hates none.
>10.099.02 Armed with the bright lightning he goes to the (scene of)
>adoration; endowed with might he has seated himself on the spacious place
>(of sacrifice); he (is) triumphant with his companions (the Maruts); the
>wiles of his seventh brother do not (prevail) at the rite. [His seventh
>brother: bhra_tuh = one who has to share in distribution; seventh: the
>seventh of the A_dityas, Dha_ta_ etc.; perhaps the ra_ks.asa_ heti is
>These and other Rks may be found at
>Rsi is Vaikhaanasa, Devata is Indra and Chanda is Trishtup
>> These Riks correspond to the question by vAlmIki to nArada and nArada's
>> reply in the very first chapter of the vAlmIki rAmAyaNa.
>Is there a difference of interpretation/translation because of different
>traditions interpreting/translating thise Rks differently?
bhava shankara deshikame sharaNam
Archives : http://lists.advaita-vedanta.org/archives/advaita-l.html
Help : Email to listmaster at lists.advaita-vedanta.org
Options : To leave the list send a mail to
listserv at lists.advaita-vedanta.org with
SIGNOFF ADVAITA-L in the body.
More information about the Advaita-l mailing list