govind at ISC.TAMU.EDU
Thu Oct 2 08:18:45 CDT 1997
On Thu, 2 Oct 1997, Martin Gifford wrote:
> I think some orthodox members are responding because if they don't say
> something everyone will notice they have been clearly defeated on this point.
> In fact I'd say he has already proved all his points and all the long winded
> responses to his posts on this subject are really just diplomacy to water
> down and obscure the issue and to protect peoples feelings.
Allan Curry raised some genuine questions about vedanta, and
Vidyasankar, Jaladhar, and Anand provided honest and
*straight forward* answers to these questions. Nobody tried
watering down or obscuring anything. Your statements above
seem to indicate that you have not read through these
discussions carefully, and I suggest you do so before
making such statements.
Regarding vedas: there is ocean, and in a lot of places
there are backwaters into the mainland; in some places, the
backwater might be dirty, and in some places, it might be
clear. And the ocean itself contains everything. So,
one *may* be standing in some backwater, claiming
that the ocean and the other waters are dirty, little
realizing that the water in his yard is from the same ocean.
So you have your choice. You can see the true nature of the
ocean or claim it is dirty.
More information about the Advaita-l mailing list