[Advaita-l] Whether the question of creation from Brahman is valid
narayana145 at yahoo.co.in
Thu Jul 4 02:38:32 EDT 2019
Dear Sri Sudhanshu Shekar,
I strongly feel that you should ask Brahman directly
for all the answers to your questions pertaining to HIM because the answers from HIM ONLY
will be authentic. The answers from the learned members
may not be authentic if they do not personally
know Brahman. There is no use in getting answers
which are not authentic because usually such answers
will be wrong.
With respectful namaskars,Sreenivasa Murthy
On Thursday, 4 July, 2019, 11:23:47 am IST, Sudhanshu Shekhar via Advaita-l <advaita-l at lists.advaita-vedanta.org> wrote:
"How can the world come about from nishkriya Brahman" - is it a valid
question in Advaita VedAnta? The confusion arises because this process of
"coming about" - in whichever manner - must necessarily involve change
which will contradict the nishkriyatva and changelessness of Brahman.
So my doubt is - whether this question itself is permissible to be asked in
Advaita VedAnta. My point is that this question is impermissible.
Because when we ask this question, it implies that we have got certain
"idea" about Brahman. We are imputing the dharma of "nishkriyatva" and
"changelessness" to Brahman whereas Brahman is stated as nirdharmaka. When
Shruti uses the word nishkriya or satya for Brahman, then it is not state
satyatva or nishkriyatva as the dharma of Brahman, but as lakshana of
Brahman with at intent to withdraw our vision from kriyavaan and
asatya-vastu (which can pretty well be understood).
Therefore, the very question as to how of creation from Brahman should be
impermissible in Advaita VedAnta because without having "some
understanding" of Brahman, this question is not possible AND no
understanding is possible about Brahman.
I would appreciate the views of learned members here.
To unsubscribe or change your options:
For assistance, contact:
listmaster at advaita-vedanta.org
More information about the Advaita-l mailing list