[Advaita-l] Ma Phaleshu Kadha Chana

sriram srirudra at md3.vsnl.net.in
Wed Mar 22 20:35:08 CST 2006

dear sir
Ma Phalesu must be linked to Ma te Sangostva NiKarmani...
the Secret according to Krsna is NaishKarmya...
the lucid explanation of this is found in Aurobindo's Gita rendition.
as for the student in context... what is not under your control why worry
about it? and what is under your control don't worry about it either?

----- Original Message -----
From: Rammohan, Chandrashekar <Chandrashekar.Rammohan at Arbella.com>
To: <advaita-l at lists.advaita-vedanta.org>
Sent: Thursday, March 23, 2006 12:15 AM
Subject: [Advaita-l] Ma Phaleshu Kadha Chana

> Pranams to all,
> I would like to add on to what Viswhanath Ji has said regarding what Lord
> Krishna has said in the Gita.   According to me, the phrase " Ma Phaleshu
> Kadha Chana " does not mean that we cannot expect results from our action,
> its just that we cannot influence the results, in the way we want it ,just
> because we do some action.  The english translation of that means that  "
> can only take a horse to the stable, we cannot make it drink water " .
> Say for example, a student studies hard for an exam and does well. Is he
> right in expecting good marks ??? It may sound logical from the student
> point of view to expect good marks. But once he has submitted his answer
> paper, he ceases to have control over it.  He cannot influence the results
> now.
> Consider scenario 1 ) Say for example, the examiner who corrects his paper
> was  in a bad mood or had a headache and decides to award less marks ,
> can result in the student getting far lesser marks than he deserves.
> Scenario 2 ) The answer paper is tied loose and some papers in the answer
> paper go missing before it reaches the examiner. So, the student does not
> get what marks he thought he deserves.
> Scenario 3) The examiner gets a news of a promotion at his school and is
> very happy and becomes very liberal in awarding marks and this ends up in
> the student getting more than what he deserved.
> Scenario 4) The Roll numbers of a few students gets interchanged and so,
> this could possibly lead to unexpected results.
> Scenario 5 ) There was a question paper leak detected subsequently and so,
> the entire exam process was called off and new dates get announced for a
> re-exam.
> So, we see that although, the input to the Examination paper-correction
> process is the same answer paper submitted by the student, the
> are entirely different based on different scenarios.  This is what the
> tries to pin-point as " you cannot influence" which would be the result.
> There will be some result but it could be influenced by a set of
> invisible factors.
> Although the scenarios listed above could be cited as trivial exceptions
> the norm, its more to higlight how helpless we are and it always helps to
> maintain poise and expect  any outcome with equanimity.
> Regds
> Chandrashekar
> _______________________________________________
> Archives: http://lists.advaita-vedanta.org/archives/advaita-l/
> To unsubscribe or change your options:
> http://lists.advaita-vedanta.org/cgi-bin/listinfo/advaita-l
> For assistance, contact:
> listmaster at advaita-vedanta.org

More information about the Advaita-l mailing list