[Advaita-l] Bhagavan Ramanuja and Madhva haven't written any Bhashyam on the Upanishads
shrao at nyx.net
Mon Feb 7 23:15:10 CST 2005
On Sat, 5 Feb 2005 sidha at omkarananda-ashram.org wrote:
> Dvaitadvaita. But I don't think that there is any commentary of Ramanuja
> or Madhva or Nimbarka or Vallabha available on the 12 principle
> Upanishads. I have asked many good scholars regarding this, and any such
> commentary is unknown to them. If they exist they are totally unpublished
> and unknown to the scholarly world at least here in North India. The 10
I'm afraid the scholarship of your sources leaves a great deal to be
desired. You are doing a disservice to North India by extrapolating their
incompetence all over it.
There are commentaries on all ten principal Upanishads from Madhva (who
has also written separate commentaries on the Mahabharata, the Rg Veda,
the Bhagavata Purana, besides the works you mentioned -- a uniquely large
swath). All his works are very much available; in fact, you can find some
of them at http://www.dvaita.net among other places.
> The 10 principle Upanishads have clear Advaita indications, and so do
> have the Samhitas, in that case I think it is nearly impossible that any
> of the above mentioned Acharyas has written any commentary on them. What
Again, the scholarship leaves a lot to be desired...
> Siddhartha Krishna
More information about the Advaita-l mailing list