[Advaita-l] Did Sankara have non-brahmin disciples?
satisharigela at yahoo.com
Thu Oct 14 04:51:20 CDT 2010
>4.With regards to point 3 however, shastrically can a Braahmana be a spiritual
>disciple or take mantra >deeksha, etc from a Non-Braahmana grihastha or sanyasi
Yes. But of-course not any mantra from the veda. Example a non-brAhmaNa or a
shUdra teacher cannot obviously teach people of any varNa let us say vaidika
Can he teach the tAntrIka mR^ityunjaya? Yes. But the qualification is that he
should have the appropriate tAntrIka dIkSha and the correct AchArya abhiSheka
etc and other qualifications.
So is there evidence that a shUdra teacher ever initiated brAhmaNa-s into
Yes there is. However this is not common. There were cases like that in the last
1500 years among traditional brAhmaNa-s but it must be admitted that is rare.
So any examples?
1)The saiddhAntika IshAna shiva mishra took dIkSha under a shUdra shaiva teacher
by name mUrtigaNa
IshAna shiva went on to become a great shaiva teacher and coposed a work by name
IshAna-shiva gurudeva paddhati which is still followed by some orthodox
brAhmaNa-s & non-brAhamaNa-s from Kerala.
2) The orthodox brAhmaNa gajapati, a sAmavedin similarly took dIkSha into many
tAntrika mantra-s from an avarNa i.e. outcaste.
There is at-least one person in this list whose head must be spinning as he sees
this.. :-) Dont worry I got hold of you.. you are not falling :)
Apastamba says that other vidya-s/skills can be learnt from shUdra-s & women.
What are other vidya-s? Of-course by vidya he means the traditional education in
the veda-s. By other can be meant anything like for example.. any of the 64
arts, or coming to modern days, science, engineering, etc etc and one can put
the tAntrIka vidya-s also in this category?
However this is not the only opinion: Many tAntrIka grantha-s themselves
strictly say that a shUdra can never initiate people of his own varNa, let alone
a brAhmaNa. But this IMHO should be understood as meaning those shUdra-s who do
not have the proper, tAntrIka yaGYopavIta, AchArya abhiSheka etc.
When one sees a person who has some vidya and is accomplished in the same and
capable to teach it, one should just learn it. Or one can be a loser and just
miss the opportunity with obscure and outdated notions. So whatever one is meant
for I guess...
More information about the Advaita-l mailing list