[Advaita-l] saMnyAsa and brAhmaNas (was RE: Fw: Re: waking, dreaming, sleeping as mutually supportive)
sivasenani at yahoo.com
sivasenani at yahoo.com
Mon Oct 26 23:42:36 CDT 2009
During that discussion, I had prepared a pdf of 30 odd pages of the chapter on Sannyasa in Mm. P V Kane's seminal "The History of Dharma Sastra". Sending it to everybody would be a violation of The Copyright Act. However, if somebody wants a copy of it for purposes approved (in spirit and letter) by The Copyright Act, please contact me privately.
Sent from BlackBerry® on Airtel
From: Vidyasankar Sundaresan <svidyasankar at hotmail.com>
Date: Mon, 26 Oct 2009 09:45:18
To: Advaita List<advaita-l at lists.advaita-vedanta.org>
Subject: [Advaita-l] saMnyAsa and brAhmaNas (was RE: Fw: Re: waking,
dreaming, sleeping as mutually supportive)
More than two years ago, we had a discussion thread on this list titled
"sannyAsa and jnAna," covering much of the same ground about what
the authorities say about traditional saMnyAsa and who is eligible for it.
At the time, another member of this list, Siva Senani, referred to the
extensive study published in Sri P. V. Kane's encyclopedic volumes
titled "History of Dharmasastra" and gave a number of citations from it.
I would suggest, if anyone wants to get a fully rounded picture of this,
please go back to the archives (Feb 2007) or please read Kane directly.
For our purposes here, here is what sureSvara says on bRhadAraNyaka
3. 5. 1:
trayANAm api varNAnAM Srutau saMnyAsa-darSanAt |
brAhmaNasyaiva saMnyAsa iti bhAshyaM virudhyate ||
trayANAm aviSesheNa saMnyAsaS SrUyate Srutau |
yadopalakshaNArthaM syAt brAhmaNa-grahaNaM tadA ||
karmAdhikaravicchedi jnAnaM ced abhyupeyate |
kuto'dhikAra-niyamo vyutthAne kriyate balAt ||
pratyag-yAthAtmya-vijnAna-svabhAvaS cet samarthyate |
vyutthAnaM yasya yasya syAt sa sa vyutthAtum arhati ||
sureSvarAcArya does not give specific citations here, but his reference
has to be to the same sources that the mitAkshara (commentary by
vijnAneSvara on yAjnavalkya smRti) cites -
trayANAM varNAnAM vedam adhItya catvAra ASramA iti sUtrakAra-
vacanAc ca dvijAti-mAtrasya adhikAram AhuH - this is apparently a
reference to kAtyAyana (sUtrakAra) and I presume kAtyAyana has
specific Sruti/sMrti statements in mind.
In any case, sureSvara's view is crystal clear - the traditionally approved
type of saMnyAsa is allowed to all dvija-s in the Sruti. His position is also
totally consistent with the advaita view of jnAna itself. If nothing else, it
beautifully illustrates the close interweaving of renunciation and Self-
knowledge in the advaita tradition.
The traditional adoption of saMnyAsa, at least in the advaita tradition,
involves giving up the sacred thread that was invested at the beginning
of the student period. Only one who has already had the upanayana
saMskAra can formally give up the sacred thread. Hence the word dvija
in the above references, but note that there is no strict restriction to
I would also urge a study of sUtrabhAshya 3.4.41 and 3.4.42, where
SankarAcArya quotes verses that refer to dvija (not just brAhmaNa) in
the context of those who fall away from the stringent rules of saMnyAsa
(ArUDhaM naishThikaM dharmaM yastu pracyavate dvijaH ...). If
SankarAcArya was strictly of the opinion that the fourth ASrama is
allowed only for brAhmaNas, he could have quoted other verses here,
or he could have taken the opportunity to state his own view here.
That he does not do so is indicative that sureSvara is not necessarily
going diametrically against Sankara in this regard. The disciple is only
performing his duty as an author of a vArttika and explaining the sUkta,
anukta and durukta parts of the bhAshya.
I rest my case. If somebody today wants to pit himself or herself against
such time honored authorities as authors of various dharmaSAstras and
sureSvarAcArya, it is their prerogative. I can only say, the traditional and
historical record is different, so at least acknowledge that this is what the
record is. To repeat, saMnyAsins who happen to have been born in other
varNa-s can be fully within the ambit of the vedAnta tradition and indeed
have been fully approved by the traditional authorities of advaita vedAnta.
New Windows 7: Find the right PC for you. Learn more.
To unsubscribe or change your options:
For assistance, contact:
listmaster at advaita-vedanta.org
More information about the Advaita-l mailing list