[Advaita-l] Some rebellious remarks on Sri SSS
prem d p
prem_d_p at yahoo.co.in
Thu Apr 26 13:50:01 CDT 2007
BTW, do you have any comments on section 3? I think that's the most
interesting part. I had the greatest difficulty writing that section.
dear sri rama,
ref. section 3.1 - comments on experiencer-experienced schism:
we have to admit that the post-division discrimination between seer and seen
is the essential approach to realization. however, the seen is sublated as
avidya-karya to permanently establish self in Self. here the sublation is the
ref. section 3.1 - comments on objectivity:
modern science tries to achieve objectivity by removing the subjectivity by
interposing sufficiently dead (insentient) instrumentation. The expectation is
that insentience/jadatha provides reliable, repeatable permanence to
Whereas, the method of vedanta achieves objectivity by understanding that
instead of there being just object and subject there is a third entity called
witness. Witness is not the subject, in the sense that, it is not subjected to the
phenomena, and the witness in turn does not influence the phenomena by
virtue of non-attachment or perfect disparateness. such a seer has perfect
objectivity. this seer looks at phenomena and sees sruti.
ref. section 3.5 - comments on sruti, tarka, and action:
i really cannot comment here wih any authority, yet here i go...
i stand firmly on the ground that
- jnana does not act to create or destroy, it reveals
- jnana is not action
- tarka or reasoning is action
- reasoning seeks to create, erect a superstructure, it models as it goes
- mundane anubhava is truth lost in action
- sruti is revealed truth
- sruti is non-personal in its vastness of scope, yet inner to the individual.
sruti guides like the sun, it attracts by virtue of being the brightest,
yet the words 'cover the truth like the golden orb of the sun'. sruti is the beacon
in a trackless world of phenomenon. right reason (discrimination) winds its way
the fundamental question which has to be answered is the location of
appearance of sruti. as is evident from the records of the seers of the past,
in-wards is sruti-wards. soul of sruti is located in the inner 'akasha' (dahara).
though internal, sruti makes its appearance within panchakoshas to budhi,
but is really apart & inner to them. Words cover sruti.
it is said that Vedas are created with the world at the beginning of each cycle
of srushti, it would be worth examining this in the context of the section 3 of the
SHOUT IT OUT! Tell everyone, from anywhere, that you're online on Yahoo! Messenger
More information about the Advaita-l mailing list